Favourable ITAT order: ESOP disallowance deleted, warranty and other issues sent for fresh examination
ITAT Mumbai passed a favourable order: the tax officer is told to delete the ESOP expenditure disallowance and re-examine warranty provision, intangible depreciation and 80IC issues.
By ScoutQuest · · 2 min read
- Potential tax impact
- ~₹ 68.67 crore
- Tax component
- ~₹ 57.13 crore
- Interest component
- ~₹ 11.54 crore
What happened
The company had earlier received an order from the office of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), National Faceless Appeals Centre, Delhi, for assessment year 2022-23. It shared an appeal against that order before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Mumbai, bearing No. 6019/Mum/2026. The company states it has now received a favourable order from the ITAT, Mumbai, which was received on 20th Nov 2026 at 6:48 PM.
What the tribunal directed
- Delete the disallowance of employee stock option plan (ESOP) expenditure.
- Fresh examination of the additional evidence admitted, verification of the supporting books, a reasonable opportunity of hearing to the assessee and a speaking order in accordance with law, on the disallowance of provision for warranty / after sales services and depreciation on intangible assets.
The update also records directions to delete the disallowance of the expenditure incurred for earning exempt income, and a fresh examination on the reduction in the amount claimed under section 80IC.
Money at stake
- Potential impact stated: ~₹ 68.67 crore
- Of this, tax: ~₹ 57.13 crore
- And interest: ~₹ 11.54 crore
The company adds that there is no material impact on the financials, operations or other activities of the company.
What stays open
The ESOP expenditure disallowance is directed to be deleted. The other items, including the provision for warranty / after sales services, depreciation on intangible assets and the section 80IC claim, go back to the assessing officer for fresh examination, with the supporting books to be confirmed and a hearing given before a speaking order is passed.
How to read this
This is a tax-dispute update. The company has reported it as a favourable order and has put the potential amount at ~₹ 68.67 crore, while stating the impact on its financials is not material. Because part of the matter returns to the assessing officer, those issues are to be looked at again rather than finally closed by this order.
Also from Crompton Greaves Consumer Electricals
ITAT directs tax officer to delete ESOP disallowance; warranty and intangible items to be re-examined
21 Nov 2026
Favourable ITAT order in income tax appeal; potential impact ~INR 10.23 crore
21 Nov 2026
Tax tribunal sends warranty provision disallowance back to AO for fresh examination
21 Nov 2026
More numbers
- Potential impact of the tax order₹ 68,66,59,820/-
- Tax component₹57,12,90,684/-
- Interest component₹11,53,69,136/-
Nothing here is a view, opinion or recommendation of ScoutQuest, its parent, directors or employees. ScoutQuest is a technology company: this page was assembled automatically from public sources using artificial intelligence, and may contain errors or omissions. Confirm everything against the original source before you act on it. Any use of this page is at your own risk, and neither ScoutQuest nor its parent, directors or employees accepts liability for it.